Wednesday, December 27, 2017

Fake News, Urban Legends, and Popular Stories

The following post was put on my sight about healing (tthought.com). Although it surrounds the story of a man with a disappearing tumor, today's post illustrates the hows and whys we should all be looking closer to the stories we hear from news, on the streets, in sermons and even in schools. Fake news and made up or exaggerated stories are roaming just about anywhere you read or hear.

So there is this story on the internet, in articles and in books used to illustrate how powerful the mind is. It's all about a patient (Mr. Wright) who, under the care of a certain doctor, was given medicine in 1957 that made a cancerous tumor the size of an orange completely disappear. But here is the interesting part of the story. It wasn't the medicine that dissolved the tumor, but it was the man's belief in what turned out to be a worthless medicine. His mind, and only his mind completely dissolved a large tumor. But after discovering the medicine was no good, the man relapsed and the tumor ended up killing him two days later.

As much as I believe that most successful "faith healing" is usually no more than a person's body (and the brain) reacting to expectation of a cure and trust in authority (put more simply - the placebo effect), and even though the story of the disappearing tumor would help me find clarity in an area of healing I am looking for clearer answers, something about this story seemed wrong. I think I wanted to believe the story, but the story looked to fishy. So as with many stories I read that are used to promote or confirm any doctrine or teaching (any side of the issues of today), I decided to research more about this case to see if there was truth behind the stories told.

MARKS OF MAKE-BELIEVE

Image result for urban legend
For the first few hours of research, I thought I would not be able to find the genesis of this story and that it would be nothing more than an urban-legend-like/fake-news-like tales passed on to feed the hunger of the "mind over medicine" fans. The more I searched, the more I was siding with a legendary beginning to this tale. I was beginning to conclude this was one big fake story:
  1. I could not find the source of the story. One mark of an urban legend is that most of the stories claim to happen to a friend of a friend. For example: After a trip to Mexico, my brother's friend went to a dentist because he had a large sore on the inside of his back molar. When the dentist poked the sore, dozens of baby roaches poured out into his mouth. One of the signs this is not true is that it happened to a friend of a friend. If I talk to his friend, however, I will find out that it really happened to a friend of his friend. And if I talk to that person, I will hear the same thing. I will never find the source. Mr. Wright's story seemed not to have had a real source, even though books and articles used the story.
  2. Secondly, the story seems too good to be true. This is a second sign I thought the story was probably false. When a gun toting fanatic walked into a restaurant in Washington D.C., he was convinced he would find a secret underground vault filled with Hillary Clinton's child slaves. He hated Clinton so much that he bought the story that she kidnapped children and sold them as sex slaves. Where he heard this story is a mystery to me, but not the story itself. This type of story is common the political world because such stories justify fears and hates a group has. In other words, this story for the Clinton haters was too good to be true. Mr. Wright's disappearing tumor seemed too good to be true for a group that wants to believe that modern medicine is superseded by the power of the mind.
  3. Thirdly, some of the articles emphasized that the story was true..."this is true." As soon as I read those words, I was led to believe it was probably false. Any story or news station that has to tell you it is true without good evidence should be viewed with skepticism.
  4. Fourthly, the stories varied. Variation of a story is expected with popular stories because people adjust stories to fit their purposes for writing or telling the stories. This adjusting happens because people remember certain parts of stories but not all, or adjusting may happen to serve the purposes of convincing others of the story's truth. The biggest variation of Mr. Wright's story was the purpose of the drug involved. One story says it was only used on and successful with horses. Another story states that the drug was being tested in a controlled study on others in the hospital already. And a third story tells us that Mr. Wright had to demand being included in the trial. Each of these stories tell us that Mr. Wright had to force the Doctor to comply with his wishes.
Another variation is in the doctor's name. One article called him Dr. West and another said it was Dr. Klopfer. Once again, this is a sure sign that the story has been evolving. Nevertheless, even stories that have the earmarks of urban legend type of evolution can come from some story that started it all. So I began digging more into the story.

Dr. Klopfer
THE ORIGIN OF THE STORY

I searched the names of the doctors and found one of them led me closer to the source. After several hours of searching the internet, I got closer to the source of this story. It turns out that Wikipedia mentioned that Dr. Bruno Klopfer wrote an article "Psychological Variables in Human Cancer", Journal of Projective Techniques, Vol.21, No.4, (December 1957), in which he described Dr. Wright's condition and response to a bogus medicine called "Krebiozen."

Finding out who the originator of this story was, I wanted to know who he was and if he was some quack. Wikipedia told me that he studied under Karl Jung (impressive), did research at Columbia University (equally impressive), and finally appointed Clinical Professor of Psychology at the University of California in Los Angeles. All of these titles give weight to the fact that the story of the disappearing tumor is legit and that the mind can in fact reduce the size of tumors and may even be able to destroy them entirely. However, being closer to the source and being impressed with the doctor's position, I still have my doubts. I suppose the biggest problem I had was that even though I was close to the source, I could not find the article itself and read what Dr. Klopfer himself wrote about Dr. Wright.

THE ETHICS OF MEDICINE RESEARCH

Several years ago I taught Medical Ethics in a local University. In my studies at that time, I discovered a commonly used trick among researchers and developers. In order to get the money needed to continue research, companies and researchers often falsify their findings, believing that further funds will help them to prove their theories right and thus pay off in the end for investors and for researchers. But this is a tricky deal with the devil, for while it pays off for many (it paid off for Steve Jobs on several occasions), it can backfire if further research does not produce the expected results.

Image result for Woo Suk HwangOne South Korean researcher, Woo Suk Hwang (in 2004-2005) claimed he had been able to produce cloning from embryonic cells because he was convinced he could with enough money. After being awarded the finances he needed, he was unable to produce his expected findings and went from the country's hero to his country's shame. "He lost his university position and his two important papers on embryonic stem cell research had to be retracted from the journal Science (http://stemcellbioethics.wikischolars.columbia.edu/The+Cloning+Scandal+of+Hwang+Woo-Suk)."

I knew that even the best scientists and teachers can make mistakes or even manipulate their findings. Could Dr. Klopfer have created the story of the disappearing tumor in order to impress his peers and the Journal of Projective Techniques' readers? Did he exaggerate something that happened? Or was he an eye witness to the amazing power of the human body? I wonder if reading the original article would help me answer these questions, but because I don't have the original, I cannot conclude properly. The story of Mr. Wright is not helpful in getting closer to what goes on with faith healing.

ANOTHER CASE FROM MEDICAL JOURNALS

I am still not convinced Dr. Klopfer really saw a tumor dissolve so quickly and so easily. Dr. Klopfer was writing a book and needed illustrations to prove his point and I cannot honor people who are popular or educated on the basis of their popularity or position. I am afraid that I would have to see it or learn more about it in order to believe it.

The story sounds too urban legend-like for me to accept it without further proof, but as I mentioned, whether or not it happened, the stories that came from this article took a life of their own.

On the other hand, there is another story that likewise moves through generations of story tellers. Dr. Mason (1951) who treated a teen with arms covered in warts. "Most of the boy's body -- everything but his face, neck, and chest -- was covered in a "black horny layer" of skin that Mason said 'felt as hard as a normal finger-nail, and was so inelastic that any attempt at bending resulted in a crack in the surface, which would then ooze blood-stained serum (http://www.radiolab.org/story/299045-hypnotist-and-warts/).'"
Image result for dr. mason warts
From Dr. Mason's original report

Dr. Mason used hypnosis (the placebo effect was not yet well known in 1951) and told the boy that one of his arms would clear up in two weeks. The repeated stories (even by NPR) tell us his arm completely cleared up, but the original report (I had to find the original report before I bought this story) said most of his arm cleared up.

After the doctor was told by his peers that what happened to the boy was considered impossible, the doctor was unable to help the teen any further. The doctor blamed his inability to further healing to his lack of belief in the possibility of healing to continue after finding out that what he did was impossible.

Why do I believe this story and not Dr. Klopfer's? Dr. Klopfer's story is too good. It fits too well within the framework of his book and there are no contradictions or failures in Dr. Klopfer's story. It is all too black and white. Dr. Mason however fails in further attempts to help the person.

Another reason I accept Dr. Mason's story is because I can get to the source, see the pictures and read from his experience first hand, as Dr. Mason worked with other doctors and filled out an official report with pictures and statistics which can be read by all (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2021155/pdf/brmedj03456-0026.pdf).

All in all, I conclude that the disappearing tumor story may be true, but without further proof, I don't have enough evidence to buy it to use it in further investigation.

THE DISAPPEARING TUMOR AND FAITH HEALING

I wrote this article because it demonstrates how important research is in the area of healing. A lot of people pass on stories and testimonies because such stories make people feel good, support opinions, "glorify God," and so on. However, even true stories change with each retelling, so in order to get to the bottom of each story, it is important to research.

Many stories will have no known source or sources that cannot be trusted. Most of these stories should be rejected, even when and especially when they support what you want to believe, whether you believe in faith healing or do not believe.

Finally, when I first began reading about Dr. Klopfer and Mr. Wright, I was hoping to find evidence (either way) if a tumor could disappear from a placebo effect or from a healing crusade. Unfortunately, I did not find the answer to this...at least, not yet.

This post is what I wrote for my site on healing. The principles of research should be taken as well into other areas as well. In fact, try taking the next real good juicy story you hear that claims to be true, research to find its source, and compare the differences.

Thursday, September 14, 2017

Why Are There so Many Hurricanes?



"It is time to destroy all who have caused destruction on the earth."
Revelation 11:18

The U.S. was just hit with two massive hurricanes which came on the heals of a total lunar eclipse. Is the world coming to an end? Is the U.S. being judged by God? Are we doomed for more tragedy?

THE ANCIENT WORLD

If I borrow from ancient culture, then by all means, God or gods are unhappy with the South and is punishing Florida and Texas. When a bridge collapsed in Minneapolis killing 13, I never heard mention that God was angry with those 13 people who died, but when a building collapsed in Jesus' day, killing 18 people, the story was told that those 18 somehow deserved what happened because they had sinned (Luke 13:4). Jesus told his followers that those people were not bigger sinners than the rest of them and he warned them that something worse was coming if they did not turn from their sins. In the Bible days, every natural tragedy outside of war was related to sin.

Natural tragedies were not the only disasters tied to sin. When Jesus and his disciples walked up to a man blind from birth, the disciples asked Jesus, "Who sinned that he was born blind?" For them the question was not, "Did sin cause this blindness?" For them, somebody sinned because this man was born blind. Jesus told them that nobody sinned to cause this. At this point his wording gets a bit tricky, because he added, "but that the work of God might be revealed." Or he may have said, "Let the work of God be manifested." The original Greek can go either way. So either this man's was born blind for the sole purpose of revealing God's work or Jesus was simply saying that no one sinned to cause this blindness, nevertheless, let God be glorified.

When someone could not speak in the days of Jesus, it was commonly held that demons were possessing the dumb and not allowing them to speak. Jesus worked and healed in a world where sin and demons were behind most diseases and natural disasters.

THE ANCIENT WORLD'S INFLUENCE ON TODAY

Not many hold to a purely ancient world view when it comes to modern disasters. We know so much more about the reasons why structures collapse and how people get sick. Even so, there are many who cling to the ancient world views to some degree or another.

When Haiti was hit with a major earthquake that killed tens of thousands, Pat Robertson said the reason the earthquake killed so many was because some 200 years ago the Haitians made a pact with the devil to find freedom from the French.

In the aftermath of recent flooding and destruction in Florida and Texas, plenty of YouTube preachers are saying that this is the beginning of the end. Destruction is the result of sins such as abortion and homosexuality.

Anne Graham Lotz suggests that the recent total eclipse was a warning to the U.S. that bad times could be coming if we didn't change our ways.

In some Christian circles, being sick is often related to sin.

These people hold on to some degree much of the ancient world's reasons for natural disasters and sicknesses.

Most of these Christians blend modern science with ancient thought. They can see that a disaster might be the result of poor building construction. They can see that a disease such as arthritis is brought on by natural wearing and tearing of the body. But many of them also believe that God causes such things or lets such events happen for different reasons (IE: testing our faith, punishment for sin).

GLOBAL WARMING

There is a not so friendly debate going on in the U.S. in general - Christians and non-Christians are siding into one of several schools of thought.

The first camp tells us that the storms and disasters are probably due to global warming. This camp can be further divided into two sub camps. The first agrees that there is global warming but says that the warming is a natural phenomenon unrelated to human activity. The second camp believes that humans contribute to global warming. Both of these camps are willing to accept that global warming may be contributing to an increase of random and/or unusual changes in weather which can include stronger and more hurricanes, tornadoes, hotter temperatures, rising oceans and so on.

On the other hand, there are people who claim that global warming does not exist. Some of these people believe that scientists are political beings who are finding what they want to find with a political agenda in mind.

Either way, the evidence is strong that global warming is happening at an alarming rate. We may not see any drastic change in the next few years, but changes are going to come.

YIPPEE! THE WORLD IS FALLING APART

Image result for hurricane irma

There are those who believe disasters such as the hurricanes that hit Florida and Texas are sign that Jesus is coming back. Jesus is coming and they are happy to see the world fall apart as it's demise means the soon return of Jesus. Most of these people see the disasters as a result of human sin which God punishes when He has had enough. In many of these people's belief, Jesus promised to keep the godly safe by taking them bodily into heaven while the rest of the world will get worse and worse and suffer more and more. So if the world is falling apart, it is okay.

LET'S GO TO MARS

Then again, there are people like Bill Gates and Stephen Hawking who believe the planet cannot survive another 100 years because of global warming, overpopulation, and Artificial Intelligence. They believe we need to start looking into the possibility of populating another planet.

HELP!

The world could be ending in a few generations. Disaster after disaster could be on the rise killing many of us in the prime or our lives. The future could be very dark for humanity. What should we think about all this?

When I was a young member in the U.S. Coast Guard, a group of us had just finished eating at a restaurant and were paying a hostess for our food. One of the guys (Joe), who was a bit strange and told the hostess, "Jesus is coming back tomorrow!" The hostess was startled when he said that. She looked like she believed him, so I took over the conversation to cover up for my friend's stupidity. "No he's not coming back tomorrow, but if he was, would you be ready?"

The hostess told me she was not ready, so before other customers came to pay for their food, I told her she could take time that night and pray to God and rededicate herself to Christ (I assumed that she had some sort of Christian background by the way she reacted to Joe). She said she would.

The hurricanes and the eclipse may not have had anything to do with God's judgment and may not be signs at all that Jesus is coming back. But if they are...are you ready?













Monday, September 11, 2017

What Is the Unforgivable Sin?

When I was much younger, a lot of people were very concerned that they had committed the unforgivable sin that Jesus talked about in Mark 3:22-30 and Matthew 12:22-32.

I used to talk to people on the street and they would bring up the unforgivable sin and tell me they were concerned because they were convinced they had committed the unforgivable sin. As a young Christian I always assured them that if they had committed such a horrible transgression, they would not be concerned about it at all.

My theory was this:

1. If someone is concerned or wants to come to Christ, only the Holy Spirit could put this desire and concern in their hearts, because the Bible says, "No one can come to me unless the Father...draws him.
2. Those who committed the unforgivable sin in the Bible did not want anything to do with Jesus.

WHAT IS THE UNFORGIVABLE SIN?

Both Mark and Matthew record an event when religious leaders publicly told those who were with Jesus that his power was from Satan. Jesus responded by telling them how their logic made no sense at all. After demonstrating their failure in logic, he told the group that all sins were forgivable but blasphemy of the Holy Spirit. The leaders accused Jesus' power - the Holy Spirit - of being the demonic. That was blasphemy against the Holy Spirit and that was a sin that was unforgivable.

CONCLUSIONS

If you still hunger for truth; if you desire to become or stay Christian; if you want to please God; then you have not committed the unforgivable sin.

Friday, April 22, 2016

How Social Media Creates Paranoia in Relationships

THE GREAT SIDE

The social media is an amazing tool bringing lots of great things for this world.

When my wife and I were dating, when I lived 2,000 miles away from her, I looked forward to Sundays when I talked to here one time a week on a pay phone for 45 minutes.

Today, when a couple live 2,000 miles apart, they can Skype, FaceTime, call every day, and share time together so much more than when I was dating. These are amazing and wonderful advances in technology and social life.

The advances in social media are wonderful, but social media brings a dark side to the good side.

THE GRAY SIDE

First of all, before I get into the dark side, I will talk about the gray side - the side that is okay, but not the best. When couples from different states and countries meat online, it creates a difficulty in the relationship, in that, the couple has a hard time meeting face to face and maintaining a good relationship.

THE DARK SIDE

When couples finally commit to each other, there are other pursuers online who will always be there for each individual in the relationship.

When I was dating, I could leave one relationship and move on to another without knowing much of my past fling.  Also, if I have an interest in other people outside of the one I am moving on to, I was limited to people I could see face to face. Today, if I move from one person to another, I can look into the internet and find a bunch of interested pursuers, The temptation is far beyond what I had when I was dating. This issues surfaces even more when I get married, settle down, and get into fights with my marriage partner.

There is another dark side issue in social media. If I start dating or marry someone, I can now search for who they are talking to on the internet, thus creating new challenges and jealousies. This creates within me a paranoia which hurts my relationship with my spouse or person I am dating.

When I got married, my wife worked at a company that I had no ties to. I didn't know if there were men in her company who were hitting on her, and I would never know.

Today, if I was young and my wife was working, I could look into the social media and find the people who had crushes on her, or who worked with her, or had contact with her. And I could search out who might like her, for after all, she is a very good looking woman. And there would be people who liked her, and who hit on her, and who would make me jealous.

In this case, social media, which was designed to make life better, created a monster of jealousy and paranoia within me.

Thursday, March 17, 2016

Christian Discipleship Movements in the Late 20th Century

Jesus had many disciples (he sent out 70 on one occasion), but only 12 who were called out from the rest. These 12 would eventually be called Apostles. Form the 12 Peter, James, and John were were in his inner most circle. James and John were cousins to Jesus - his mother (Mary) was sister to their mother.
Disciples of Jesus in those days were people who were able to follow Jesus from town to town. The 12 followed him during most of Jesus' ministry - as for the others, there is no mention of how long they followed Jesus - although we do have at least 2 others from Acts 1 who followed Jesus every bit as much as the 12. 
There are cultures today where men will leave their family for years to study in Bible schools in the West, but we in the U.S. do not usually leave our families for training. The Apostle Peter stayed with his wife after he followed Jesus during his ministry, so his ministry after the resurrection was much more like ours today where we usually work together and stay with our families.
Different cultures in the ancient world had their share of disciples who followed one person (a rabbi, a sage, a prophet, a philosopher, a political leader, or whoever could gather a following). I believe this was the most effective way to learn in a world with few books and where most people could not read or go to some school. Discipleship was like a school under the tutelage of one person who was often trained under someone else. 
According to Matthew, Luke, and Mark, the disciples didn't know Jesus was the messiah until after they were his disciples for quite a while, saw his miracles, and wondered who he really was before finally realizing Jesus was the Christ after Jesus asked them, "Who do you say that I am?" So when they began to follow him they probably only thought of Jesus as a teacher of the Law who was trained under John the Baptist.
Following one person was a cultural necessity for finding the best opportunity to learn. I think we have so much more opportunity in our day and following one person is not as important as it was in that world.
FOLLOWERS
I believe that many people followed Jesus because they saw miracles or had hopes of him being the warrior messiah, but Jesus had a group of disciples who he called out to be trained under his teachings. They were his students. To me, followers were not really disciples wanting to learn, be corrected, and grow. Instead, followers looked for quick fixes and surface level, me-centered experiences.
EXCEPTIONS
Sometimes Jesus did call his disciples followers; so it is not completely accurate to make such a differentiation between the two groups.
TODAY'S DISCIPLESHIP
This historical look is the foundation of what it means to be a disciple of Jesus. Of course, we do not follow the earthly Jesus, we follow the risen Christ, so it is different. Modern discipleship is not usually sitting at the feet of one earthly person called Jesus, but sitting at the feet of many people who teach, preach, and live out the gospel. Through them, we sit at the feet of the risen Christ.
THREE GROUPS THAT TRIED INTENSE DISCIPLESHIP
Three groups since the 1970s have tried to pursue a higher level of discipleship. 
The International Church of Christ under Kip McKeen developed a college centered intense discipleship. Baptism was all considered null unless one was baptized into discipleship and when one joined their group, that person submitted to an elder who submitted to one above him. The group eventually fell apart after gaining more than 500,000 followers because Kip McKeen realized that the group was too tightly controlled and abuse abounded. He quit his own group and overnight the church folded, leaving missionaries overseas stranded without support.
The Shepherding Movement was the design of 5 Charismatic leaders who designed the same intense discipleship that Kip did (although the Shepherding Movement came first). These 5 leaders set up shepherds who shepherded people, telling them what they could do and not to do, what they could wear, who they could date (I lost a fiance to the group), and so on. In a couple of years, 2 of the 5 leaders publicly repented of what developed saying their idea of discipleship was a bad idea. Another one claimed the Body of Christ was not ready for shepherding. I don't know about the other two. Perhaps they just wanted to quietly slip away unnoticed.
As much as we want so much to follow Christ to the extreme, we have to be careful. In the world of New Religions and Cults, high demand discipleship has not been good. Following Christ under a canopy of freedom is scary because of our sinful nature, but it is the best way to serve Christ with our whole hearts. 
One exception to this is Youth With a Mission Discipleship Training School. They live under high demands, but it is only for 5 or 6 months. That is probably why they have not fallen apart after a year or two.
All three get legalistic in their attempts to follow Jesus.

Saturday, February 20, 2016

Why Is Donald Trump so Popular with Evangelicals?

FIRST OF ALL I need to clarify why I am writing about Donald Trump in my blog about Christianity.

The Bible is filled with politics and Evangelicals in the U.S. generally love Donald Trump who seems to know almost nothing about the Bible.  Not all Evangelicals support Donald Trump, but a large enough group of them do for me to want to take a closer look at this phenomenon.

THE REASONS EVANGELICALS ARE PREPARED TO LIKE DONALD TRUMP are as follows:

1.  Evangelicals have placed their hopes in the Republican party after failing to begin their own party.

2.  Evangelicals learned about politics from Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, Francis Schaefer, James Dobson, and other Evangelical leaders who learned that working with the enemy was vital in politics (as long as that enemy can further common interests). As a result, for some issues, Jerry Falwell, Hal Lindsey, and other Evangelical leaders united with and worked with Sun Myung Moon who proclaimed himself ruler of the world the completion of Jesus' failed ministry.

3. Many Blue-Collar Evangelicals have been listening to right winged radio show hosts who simplify politics, and demonize everything outside of the Conservative circle. Through these political pundits, Conservatives learn where to direct fears, hates, and angers while getting an education in the political world from a conservative and fear based world view.

4. Evangelicals have focused on small group of issues and Evangelicals will support any politician who support these issues (as long as they are Republican - because in their thinking only Republicans will believe and behave as they do).

Some of these issues are:

a.  Homosexuality

b.  Prayer in public schools (Evangelicals are already moving on from this one)

c.  Abortion (Catholics were 5 years ahead of the Evangelicals in fighting abortion, but once Evangelicals got on board, they have been strongly anti abortion since).

d.  Turning the country back to where it once was. This is pipe dream based in a glorified and false view of the past that many believe existed. I think most cultures fall into this "once upon a time" in some way or another. Even the writer of Ecclesiastes saw it in his day, "Do not say, 'Why is it that the former days were better than these?' For it is not from wisdom that you ask about this (Ecclesiastes 7:10)."

e.  Simple solutions for simple problems. In its most simple state, the picture looks like this:
1) The country was founded by good Christians who fled persecution in Europe.
2) The country used to be ruled by godly people who established godly rules.
3) The ungodly poisoned the well with evolution, and liberal thinking.
4) When prayer was taken out of public school, the country was doomed.
5) We need to fight to turn this country back to its roots and the best way to do that is through politics and prayer.


THE REASON EVANGELICALS LIKE DONALD TRUMP is that he gives them hope and promise to turn this country back to its legendary roots by draining the swamp and holding on to conservative values.

1. He is simple. He offers simple solutions and simplifies complex issues. Evangelicals, like most people, don't want life to be complex and difficult to understand. They want to understand and be able to solve life's issues without getting too bogged down with too much detail. There is a strong belief among many that life doesn't need to be complex.

Most politicians gravitate toward simplifying and handing out sound bites, but Donald Trump stands out in this area by providing the simplest answers and solutions. "Build a fence to keep Mexicans out." "Keep foreigners out."

Voters are tired of politicians who make everything complex.

2.  He is a bully. Many conservatives are tired of wishy-washy politicians that tip toe around issues and other countries. Conservatives would say that Donald Trump has balls and whether right or wrong, he stands up to his convictions.

3.  He has a well-known brand. Americans have seen him for years on TV as a boss who hires and fires celebrities. In his show, he is definitive (he rarely makes mistakes and never admits them), he is authoritative (celebrities kiss up to him), he is a family man (his two kids sit by his side and offer their opinions on who should stay and who should be fired), and he is successful, having built an empire few people have in this world. All of this adds up to a powerful image and image has been huge in politics since the Kennedy / Nixon debates. None of the other candidates have anything close to the brand that Trump brings to the table.



Thursday, February 11, 2016

The Book of Enoch and the New Testament


 Elijah walked with the Angels.
(Genesis 5:24)

The Book of Enoch is a controversial book that almost made it in the Bible, but just narrowly missed the cut. Jude quoted directly from Enoch, Peter and Jude both referred to its contents, and Jesus may have borrowed from Enoch when he talked about angels never needing to marry - Enoch explains that the angels don't need to marry and have children because they never die.

Opinions are divided over whether or not Enoch is good, bad, or whatever. Conspiracy theorists and sellers of magazines and TV programs want to turn the book into another "proof" the Church is hiding something and Fundamentalists demonize the book.

I am not going to say one way or another. You can figure that one out on your own. Rather I am only going to point out how Enoch is clearly behind some of the thinking of New Testament writers - especially Peter and Jude.

Because we have such limited information from the world in which Bible writers lived, we cannot piece together the entire ancient world and their ways of thinking. That limits us to only what we do have and what we know from the books and fragments we have.

For those readers who are not familiar with the Book of Enoch, the book itself claims to be written by Enoch (the 7th from Adam - who was born before Noah) but in fact was written by several scribes at different times - long after Enoch lived. Writing under a famous person's name and on behalf of that person was very popular during the centuries before and after Jesus' day.

In this writing I am focusing only on those parts of Enoch that were written before Jesus was born.

We do know that the first 36 chapters or so were written long before the New Testament (possibly 250 years or so before), so the similarities found in the New Testament with the Book of Enoch came from the Book of Enoch and not the other way around. However, the source of any similarity Enoch has with the Old Testament came from the Old Testament itself, for it was written first.

SUMMARY OF CHAPTERS 1-10

Section One

Enoch prophesied that a big change was on its way. Wickedness was going to disappear while godliness was going to rise. A time of prosperity and blessing was going to come on the earth.

Jude, who was the brother of Jesus, quoted from and gave credit to the Book of Enoch:
And behold! He cometh with ten thousands of His holy ones
To execute judgment upon all,
And to destroy all the ungodly:
And to convict all flesh
Of all the works of their ungodliness which they have ungodly committed,
And of all the hard things which ungodly sinners have spoken against Him.
1 Enoch 1:9

Section Two

After informing us that a new day was coming, Enoch recounts how his world became filled with violence and chaos within the spiritual and natural realms. He explains that there is order in the created world with such things as stars, the universe, the trees, and the like; nevertheless the people and the angels of his time were not following God's decrees. They were unnatural and doing things they were not designed to do. This reminds me of Isaiah 1, where God tells his people that the ox knows its master, but His people do not know theirs.

God will punish those who do not follow His commandments - they will die young. On the other hand, godly people will live long. This concept of long life for the righteous vs. life cut short for the ungodly is found in the early chapters of Proverbs.

Section Three

Sex with Angels

19 angels - each over 10 other angels (190 in total) - submit themselves to Semjaza in an agreement to take wives from among humans. They do this because they lust after good looking women.

Genesis 6:2 – the Sons of God saw the daughters of men that they were fair; and they took them wives of all which they chose.





1 Corinthians 11:10 – For this cause ought the woman to have power (authority or covering) on her head because of the angels.

Secrets Tools of Seduction

As the serpent promised Eve knowledge that only God and the angels knew, the angels in Enoch's book shared heaven's secrets with the people before Noah's day. They taught men how to war and how to make weapons. They also told women how to make themselves attractive with make-up and how to use mirrors, sorcery, astrology, charms, enchantments, cutting roots, and knowledge of plants.

1 Peter 3:1-6 tells wives not to wear make-up, but rather focus on inward beauty, submitting to their husbands and calling them "lord." Due to the fact that Peter refers to the fallen angels of Enoch in verses following, this section about make-up could be influenced by a belief (perhaps common in some circles of Israel) that make-up was one of several tools fallen angels taught women in order to seduce men.

In the early chapters of Proverbs, the writer describes a seduction that gives us insight into the ancient mind. The story is about a man and a woman having an adulterous affair. In the story, the man is seduced by a woman who has no morals. Although he could escape the affair, the power of seduction is strong and the man gives into it. Seduction was the power women had to entrap men and seduction was augmented by the gifts and tools the angels gave women.

If tools for seduction, such as make-up, were considered forbidden secrets from the fallen angels, then make-up was probably considered taboo in many Hebrew circles. Is it possible that Peter felt the same?

Giants

The offspring of these angels and human women in Enoch turned out to be giants that ravished the land.
                       
Genesis 6:4 – There were giants (Nephalim) on the earth in those days, and also afterward, when the sons of God came in to the daughters of men and they bore children to them. Those were the mighty men who were of old, men of renown.

Eventually these giants consumed more than the earth could provide. They killed animals and people. Violence and death increased and the cries of the earth reached heaven itself.  

The Good Angels 

Meanwhile, in heaven Michael, Gabriel, Raphael, Suryal, and Uriel heard and cries of the earth and talked to God about it wondering why God was so silent.

God gave one of them a message to pass on to Noah that things are going to get wet. He gave another message for the angels that sinned - their children were going to die. It turns out that their spirits roam the earth as unclean spirits that were so commonly spoken of in the New Testament.

The good angels also bound up all the bad ones and sent them into the fires under the earth (after all the earth is flat in the Book of Enoch) for 70 generations. Luke 3 records that from Enoch to Jesus there were 70 generations. Is this just coincidence or did Luke intend his readers to see that Jesus was the one who would take care of those who were bound at the end of 70 generations?

It is possible 1 Peter 3:19-20 also refers to the importance of Jesus in the 70th generation: "And being made alive, he went and made proclamation to he imprisoned spirits - to those who were disobedient long age when God waited patiently in the days of Noah while the ark was being built."
 
According to the Book of Enoch, the bad angels were to be cast into fire for eternity after 70 generations from Enoch himself.

For if God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down to hell, and delivered them into chains of darkness, to be reserved unto judgment,... (2 Peter 2:4, see also Jude 1:6).







Saturday, February 6, 2016

What the Bible Says about Accepting Refugees?

In the past few years wars and famine have brought tremendous ruin to Middle Eastern and African countries which has resulted in hundreds of thousands of people leaving their homes and looking for survival in Western countries.

Their journeys are often fought with peril and death and many are unable to leave their countries because of hardships or blocked avenues.

Several years ago, I worked with African refugees from different countries. They left starvation, death, and human corpses littering the rivers they drank from. One boy in our group was kidnapped from his village and made a slave in another part of his country. After fellow slaves tried unsuccessfully to escape, they were caught and their heels were cut so that the would never be able to walk again. The boy was smarter and waited for a better time, escaped, hugged the top of a box car of a train, and made it to freedom. Shortly after he was shipped to the U.S. as an orphan.

There were many such stories among the Africans, many of which were kept securely within the memories of those who experienced them.

Before Israel became a nation, when they were only a small group of nomads and people who lived outside of their group were not trusted. Because of this distrust, the nomads kept to themselves and usually married within the family. Both Abraham and his son Isaac were so paranoid about outsiders that they told city dwellers that their wives were sisters. They believed that outsiders would kill them for their wives, and rather than facing an imaginary death, they contrived a plan to pass their wives off as sisters. This worked very well for Abraham as he walked away with a load of money, servants, and goods, just to leave Egypt where he humiliated Pharaoh through his trickery.

Years later he duped the king of Gerar who was appalled at Abraham for being so xenophobic in assuming that because he wasn't family to Abraham he was immoral. Abraham assumed that the outsider would be evil and do evil things, but in fact, Abraham's trickery was downright wrong and the king of Gerar who had been tricked let Abraham know it.

As Israel grew into a nation they faced many new challenges with outsiders. They were first welcomed by Egypt, but as they became more numerous, they became Egyptian slaves. Nevertheless, after finding freedom, Israel got its own land and faced a new challenge with outsiders. As different countries faced famine, people came into Israel for survival. And as Israel faced famine, many Israelis left for other countries looking for food. Besides this, intermarriage with outsiders was not uncommon.

While all of this took place, many people were fearful and hateful of outsiders. Xenophobia flooded the land from time to time, and some individuals never let their prejudices go.

Before Israel had their own land, before they developed a strong identity beyond being mere slaves, Moses left them certain laws about how to deal with outsiders. While many of those laws stated that foreigners were to live under the rules of Israel, other laws demanded that the people respect, take care of, and treat foreigners as equals.

Do not mistreat or oppress a foreigner, for you were foreigners in Egypt (Exodus 22:21).

Do not go over your vineyard a second time or pick up the grapes that have fallen. Leave them for the poor and the  foreigner. I am the LORD your God (Leviticus 19:10).

The foreigner residing among you must be treated as your native-born. Love them as yourself, for you were foreigners in Egypt. I am the LORD your God (Leviticus 19:34).


People don't really change. We have prejudice an hatred today and there was prejudice and hatred in the ancient world. The laws of Israel were written to address issues of xenophobia. The laws of the Bible written years ago fit for today as well.
 

Friday, January 1, 2016

Esther and the Battle with Feminism

The book of Esther tells the readers that being submissive is so powerful that it can save a nation.

THE SETTING

- The King of Persia and Media boasted about his possessions and showed them to everyone in the government for 6 months.
- The King held a week long party for his friends and servants showing off his palace wealth.
- By the King's command everyone was to drink as much as they wanted. They could vomit, pass out, piss in their clothes... as much as they wanted - it was the command.
- The King was very drunk on the seventh day of his party.
- At the height of his pride and showing people his wealth, the King ordered his wife, who was the queen, to come to the party so he could show her off because she was so good looking.
- She refused to come.
- The king got angry.
- All the rulers were afraid this would turn into kind of a woman's liberation movement throughout the kingdom, with women refusing to obey their husbands.
- The king divorced his wife and took all her property away from her.
- The king set up a law for all the land - women must obey their husbands.

Setting Summaries
- The king was a vain man.
- The King partied in extremes, gloated in extremes, showed off in extreme, and had sex in extremes.
- The King was not a good example of a leader, husband, or a man.
- The queen's refusal to submit to the most ridiculous commands was viewed as a threat, not only to the King's authority, but to the authority of men everywhere.
- Men feared losing total control of their wives.
- The best way to deal with a disobedient wife was to send her away without possessions or a home.

CALL FOR A BEAUTY CONTEST

-The King called for young girls to be brought from all over the world to compete in a contest to be queen.
- The judge of the contest was the King.
- The King took each girl into his bedroom for one night of sex.
- After the one night, most of the girls would remain in the castle, have food and a place to stay, but would never again sleep with a man for the rest of their lives. She would be one of the king's many concubines.
- If the King liked a girl, he would call her by name and have another night with her.

Contest Summaries

Names were important to the ancient world. To be given a name was equal to be given recognition and worth. These girls meant nothing until they were called a second time to have sex with the King.

ESTHER

- Esther was orphaned and in her uncle's care.
- Esther was probably very young and won everyone's hearts.
- Esther was probably very good looking.
- Esther is portrayed in the book as obedient to her uncle in all things.
- Only her uncle knew she was Jewish.
- After a night or two with Esther, the King chose her to be queen.

MORDECAI

- Mordecai was Esther's uncle and guardian.
- Mordecai worked at the palace.
- Mordecai overheard a plot to kill the king, reported it, and saved the king's life.

HAMAN

- Haman was made second most powerful man in the kingdom.
- Haman was arrogant and demanded people bow before him.
- Esther's uncle (Mordecai) did not bow before Haman because he was Jewish.
- Haman requested for and received an order from the king to kill Mordecai and the all the Jews.
- Events turned on Haman and he had to honor Mordecai.
- Haman and his friends saw the turn of events as a portent of what is to come.

IN THE PALACE

- Mordecai told Esther to talk to the king on the Jew's behalf.
- Esther was afraid her husband may kill her for entering his presence without being called, but because her uncle refused to back down, she took her life in her hands and asked to see her husband.
- The king welcomed her and she invited him and Haman to a party.
- During the party Esther told the king that she was Jewish and was ordered to die with all the Jews.
- The king had Haman hanged and put Mordecai in his place as 2nd in power.

CONCLUSIONS

The Book of Esther tells a story in extremes and stereotypes. It is anti-Gentile in that Gentile men in the story are powerful, but they are buffoons, sexually permissive, and arrogant. On the other hand the Jewish servant and his Jewish niece are leader worthy and very wise (Esther's wisdom is found in that she listens and obeys her Jewish uncle and in that she is submissive to her Gentile husband).

Gentile women as demonstrated from the first queen in the story are brash and disobedient. On the other hand, Jewish women are very attractive, subservient, and catch the attention of everyone around them.

The book of Esther poses problems in that Esther (who is a fine Jewish girl) is given by her uncle to a pig of a man. Mordecai also protects the Gentile overlord. Esther becomes the wife of a Gentile man who has many concubines and who is recently divorced. These problems troubled the Jewish rabbis who read and discussed the Book of Esther in the ancient world, but learned how to fill in the blanks of the story in order to make Esther look better to them.

Part of reading the Bible is accepting it as it is and not trying to make it fit into our own molds as the ancient rabbis tried to do and as we often do without realizing it. This story poses a lot of problems. It is not a book to celebrate women's independence and individual power, and it is not a book to use as an example in morals. Most Christians would not want their children marrying anybody like this king who was an unbeliever, abusive (Esther feared going near him without being invited), sexually permissive, a glutton, and arrogant.

On the surface this book puts down Gentiles and demeans women; but dig deeper and we find that the Book of Esther celebrates God's deliverance of His own people by using very unconventional and powerless means. It reminds us that God is not limited to independent, take charge type of people. He can use the timid to move the hands of the powerful.





Sunday, November 29, 2015

Bible Scandals


Every human community (nations, churches, religions, schools, and so on) treasures certain stories, values, and morals which are deeply rooted within.  These values and morals may be formally written down or else they are unwritten but understood by most if not all of the members of the group.

As important as they are, most members of every society stray from those rules in private, and occasionally one will stray and get caught publicly either by plan or by accident.  When those people are caught straying in public, the result is what could be called a scandal.  A scandal exposes the one caught to be the center of shame, public ridicule, and disgrace.

Because the Bible was written about real people in the context of a community it has its share of scandals.  Some of those scandals were more scandalous to their own culture than to us.  Likewise there are some things in our own cultures that would not seem so bad in theirs.  The following is a list of the five scandals common to both our culture and theirs that I found in the Bible.

NUMBER FIVE - TAMAR SEDUCES HER FATHER-IN-LAW (GENESIS 38)

Several women in the Bible took chances by risking their reputations in order to obtain something of greater value in their community.  Tamar was one of the best of them for taking that kind of risk.

When her husband died, her brother-in-law was supposed to have sex with her so she could give birth to a son which would help her standing within the community and continue her dead husband's name in the same community.  Having a son and continuing one's name within the community were highly regarded values within Tamar's community; so when after her husband died, her brother-in-law refused to give her children, and her father-in-law failed to let her have sex with the third brother-in-law; so she took a chance with her reputation to get the child she wanted.  She literally sacrificed her good reputation in order to obtain a more important value within the community.

Tamar posed as a prostitute in order to have sex with her father-in-law and thus obtain what was most important within the community - a son to carry on her dead husband's name and to promote her reputation within her community.

By posing as a prostitute, Tamar's father-in-law had the right to have her executed, and that is exactly what he demanded - until he understood that Tamar sacrificed her reputation to obtain a more important value.

NUMBER FOUR - ONAN SPILLS HIS SEED ON THE GROUND (GENESIS 38)

When I first heard Genesis 38 in a sermon, an traveling evangelist was using the story to preach against the evils of masturbation.  Onan was supposed to fulfill a community requirement by having sex with his sister-in-law Tamar, but Onan was not concerned about his brother's wife or his brother, so when he had his moment with her, rather than following through with what he committed to, he spilled his sperm on the ground.

Because he was so callous toward his brother and brother's wife, God killed him.  God killed him, not because he was masturbating, but because he purposely failed to do his community duty.  His story became a lesson to future generations about the importance and warnings involved in fulfilling community duties.

NUMBER THREE - FATHERS AND SONS HAVE SEX WITH THE SAME TEMPLE PROSTITUTES  LYING ON TOP OF GARMENTS TAKEN BY PLEDGE (AMOS 2:7)

The prophet Amos was appalled at the behavior of people around him.  He saw creditors take all that was valuable from those who could not pay their bills (in that day people who could not pay their debts lost their clothes, their houses, and those worse off would lose their children, then their wives, and last of all they would be sold into slavery to pay off their creditors).

The creditors were business men who had money and could afford to lend out at money to those who were in need.  Today if you don't pay your bills, your car or house will be taken by the banks; in those days the clothes off your back were taken before your children, you and your wife / husband would be taken.  The prophet Amos saw creditors use the cloaks they took from those who owed money, and carefully lay them on the ground in some shrine built to honor another god so the debtors could have sex with the sacred prostitutes who worked at the shrine.

While the higher class of society accepted this picture as normal, Amos spoke for God and for the poor, calling it scandalous.

NUMBER TWO - SAMSON AND DELILAH (JUDGES 16)

One would expect that a child miraculously born after the proclamation of an angel would turn out to be a dedicated man of God; but this is not the case with Samson.  Samson was a miracle baby who grew up without much common sense.  He had no real friends around him that we know of, and his own people were probably more annoyed than impressed by his behavior.

Samson was part of a small group of Hebrews who was a Nazirite, which meant that he could not touch dead bodies, shave his hair, drink wine, or eat grapes.  The Nazirites made a vow to avoid such things and live for God.  Samson was a Nazirite from the day he was born and his parents made the vow for him.

The Bible paints a clear picture that Samson cared very little for his Nazirite vow.  He took honey from the carcass of a lion, he partied with and felt more comfortable with the Philistines than with his own people (it is not stated, but he could have been drinking wine with his friends), and he told a woman that his long hair which had never been cut gave him supernatural strength.

He didn't tell just any woman his secret; he told Delilah who was a Philistine.  Delilah - who gave Samson every signal possible that she would ruin him if he let her know.  Delilah was the Philistine's tool to find the secret behind Samson's strength; and with his secret discovered, the Philistines cut Samson's hair, took out his eyes, and put him into slavery.

Samson turned his back on his own nation by ignoring them in attempts to befriend the Philistines and his Philistine girlfriends; and that became his downfall.  Samson's parents warned him of going out with women who were not of his people, but Samson ignored them because even though no one knew it at the time, his desire for foreign women"was from the LORD, who was seeking an occasion to confront the Philistines; for at that time they were ruling over Israel  (Judges 14:4)."

NUMBER ONE - ANANIAS AND SAPPHIRA (ACTS 5:1-14)

For a short period of time the early church tried to live as directed by the teachings of Jesus (as they understood it).  Many sold all they had and gave to the Apostles for distribution and the Apostles distributed to the community as people had need.  As a result the church had all things in common.

Barnabas was a rather wealthy man who owned land, sold it, gave the money to the Apostles for distribution, and through this act of giving, and for whatever other reasons not mentioned, he won a high position among the inner circle of leadership of the early church which was centered in Jerusalem at the time.

Ananias and Sapphira saw this and decided together that they would likewise sell land and give it to the Apostles for distribution.  But Ananias and Sapphira decided to keep back some of the money for their own distribution to themselves - which was not a bad idea in and of itself.  Their problem was that they wanted the Apostles and the other Christians to think they were giving all their money to the community.  They didn't want anyone to know that they were keeping back some for themselves.  For that deception, they died while people looked on.

Their story in Acts 5 concludes with these words:  No one else dared join them, even though they were highly regarded by the people.  Nevertheless, more and more men and women believed in the Lord and were added to their number (Acts 5:13-14).


Many would think the lesson of this story is that one should not try to deceive the church leadership.  But the lesson the early church received was not about lying as much as it was about holding back from the attempt to get into the inner circles of the Apostles.  In Acts 5:13-14 we read that while Christians were growing in number, no one dared to join "them."  "Them" does not refer to the Christians, but rather "them" refers to the Apostles' inner circle.  After Ananias and Sapphira failed to reach the inner circles of leadership through deceptionr, no one else dared to try in any way to enter the inner circle.

Barnabas sold land, gave to the disciples, and for whatever other reasons he joined the Apostles in leading the church.  He did not plan to become a co-leader, but it happened.   Seeing his success, Ananias and Sapphira concluded that they could likewise join the inner circles of leadership by copying Barnabas; but their plan backfired.  Just as Miriam and Aaron tried to be equal with Moses and were punished by God for doing so, the early church saw the deaths of Ananias and Sapphira as a warning to avoid attempts to become equal with the Apostles.

Friday, November 13, 2015

How People React in Response to Fallen Christian Heroes

The following are different categories I see for how people react to Christian heroes and/or celebrities who fall.  The categories are found online in discussion forums and in response / comments columns under videos and articles. 

THE INTERNET AS AN AVENUE TO OPEN UP A DIFFERENT SIDE OF SELF

For some say, “His letters are weighty and forceful, but in person he is unimpressive and his speaking amounts to nothing.”
2 Corinthians 10:10

INTRODUCTIONS

Two Sides of the Same Person 

For some say, “His letters are weighty and forceful, but in person he is unimpressive and his speaking amounts to nothing.”
2 Corinthians 10:10
 
The Corinthians accused Paul the Apostle of being 2 different people - one in his letters and another in person.  I think many of us are guilty of this problem.  It's easier to be bold and assertive in print than in person.  Paul knew that in his case, his accusers had a valid point, but he warned the Corinthians that he was just as capable of being forceful in person if needed to be.  Even though he was somewhat timid in person and bold in his writings, he was aware of the difference and preferred to keep it that way because he didn't want to be hard on the Corinthians in person.

This difference in writing vs. physical presence is clearly evident on the internet.  In fact, on the internet, the difference may become huge.  Even quiet, meek, and mild people can be brutal and scary with comments they make on the web, which is especially seen when well known Christians, politicians, celebrities, and heroes get caught in scandals.

In this blog, I will focus on scandals, both Christian and Non-Christian, of those who fall and get a lot of talk on the internet for their scandals. I will be focusing on the trash talk and discussions rather than the scandals.  But first I need to say something about modern media.

What's Wrong with the Media?

The media loves to find and expose the dirty sides of people, not because the media is some kind of evil entity feeding us unsuspecting and innocent victims, rather the media loves to find the dirt about people because we the audience want to see it, hear about it, and talk about it with others in and out of work.  Really, the media and its readers live in one big cycle.  Dirt sells because people want it, so the media digs it up and exposes it and gives it to the people so that we can have all the dirt we want.

I am reminded of a scene I saw in a most horrible movie about the life of Howard Stern.  The radio network wanted him off the air because he was rebellious, crude, immoral, and offensive.  They tried to tame him, but he wouldn't be tamed.  They couldn't let him go because of contracts, but eventually they caved in, celebrated in his success, and wanted to keep him because they found out their ratings were climbing so much.  When they researched what kind of audience Howard had, they found that listeners either loved or hated him.  The interesting thing is that the people who hated him listened just as much as the ones who loved him.  For the radio station, it didn't matter if people hated him, just as long as they turned their radio stations on to Howard Stern.

Getting viewers for better advertisement dollars is what the media seeks.  The media doesn't care about what we say we want or what we say we want; it cares about what we will be drawn to, and what we really watch (whether we are drawn in by our own disgust or admiration).  Media gives us what we will listen to or watch on a regular basis.  So it doesn't matter if you say, "That was so horrible," if you get hooked into what the media gave you.  Above I wrote how horrible the Howard Stern movie was.  I didn't like it, and felt yucky watching it.  But I watched it.

Some of the most popular videos on YouTube have such titles as "The Most..." The Best..." because it pulls in audiences that want the biggest, the scariest, the most extreme in any subject.  The media looks for extremes because extremes are what will pull us in.   We may say that the media is low down and disgusting, but it is giving a nation what they want.  We say we want it nicer, but nicer doesn't always sell.  Exposing famous people's faults sells big.

REACTIONS AND COMMENT

The Haters

For whatever reason, many of us love to hate.  We love to hate - not everyone, or anything - but we love to hate certain people, groups of people, or certain things.

We may love to hate famous people who act foolishly, over the top, or immorally like Miley Cyrus and Justin Bieber; or we may love to hate sports figures like Tom Brady and Lance Armstrong; or politicians like President Obama or George W. Bush.  I know I have had my share of people I loved to hate on.  It's so easy to hate on someone and talk trash about someone I have never met. 

Some people who are easy to hate in the U.S. are the rich and the famous.  I don't have all the reasons why this is so, but when the dirt comes out on the rich and famous (even the most loved such as Bill Cosby), haters come out in droves.
 
There are two types of dirt digging that are most appealing to people.  The first is dirt found in huge contrasts - such as when Ted Haggard, who preached against homosexuality and drugs, was discovered visiting a homosexual prostitute, having sex with him while getting high on meth.  

Whether intentionally or unintentionally, many Christians portray themselves publicly as righteous and godly while hiding their faults and failures.  When Christians have positions of authority and have publicly spoken against the very practices in which they indulged, their portrayals provide the perfect starting point for those who love to tear down the mighty, the powerful, the popular, and those who stand apart morally or socially. 

Secondly, there are exposes on people who have already found a place of hate in our hearts.  When people we despise get exposed to some immoral or nasty behavior, something inside us gloats.  President Clinton's sexual affair with Monica Lewinski was absolutely delicious to those who hated him. 


IS IT PERSECUTION WHEN A CHRISTIAN IS INVOLVED?

When the mighty fall, and when the righteous sin, there will be a lot of hate and trash talk.  When Christian preachers and celebrities fail morally, it is not persecution for Christ.  The haters will spew out their comments and trash talk because they get to gloat that someone too good to be true fell in a most shameful way.  They see the ultimate contrast as well as a confirmation that the person (or type of person) they despised all along deserved to be hated all along.

Peter, who walked with Jesus, separated persecution for Christ from things we do to screw up our lives, "For it is better, if it is God's will, to suffer for doing good than for doing evil (1 Peter 3:17)."   Peter also talked to the workers (servants) of his day telling them that suffering for doing wrong brings no credit:  "For what credit is it if you sin and are mistreated and endure it?  But if you do good and suffer and so endure, this finds favor with God (1 Peter 2:20)."

Those who sin and get flack for it have no right in crying, "Persecution!"  The Bible is clear on this.  Those who fall into a scandal should not be surprised with the backlash the face. The best they can do is weather the storm of negativity.


This is not to say that it is okay to write nasty things in comment sections.  The ancient world never dealt with comment sections and most people didn't read or write.  The closest thing they had was people barking out their opinions about leaders and rulers, and on this subject the Bible is clear.  Both Jude and Peter warned their followers to avoid talking trash about the rulers of this world (Jude 1:10 and 2 Peter 2:12) claiming that when we trash talk our leaders we are talking big about things we don't understand.

The Doubters

When a Christian leader or icon falls into some scandal, there will be a group of protectors who get mad at the haters.  Some of this group may understand the fallen hero because they too have fallen (in a less public manner), but some just hate seeing some special someone under attack from the media.

When women began to come out saying that Bill Cosby was taking advantage of them, a coworker told me his opinion that mean spirited women were attacking a good man to get money.  My coworker immediately sided with the person he knew and admired.  When parents of a High School football player exposed horrible practices done at football retreat, the community turned against the whistle blowers, even though they were exposing repeated sexual perversions done by the team with new players.  People rally around those they gave grown to love or respect; even when the ones we respect turn out to have a dark side to them.

These people like my coworker may eventually give in and realized that their hero has feet of clay, but because their hero is someone they think they know well, some will still bind themselves to the fallen person and support him or her.  Others will feel betrayed and angry for being duped.  The second group can become vocal haters.

We Are All Sinners

To protect the honor and reputation of the fallen, many of the supporters and people who mean well will use verses and sentences such as, "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone,"  "No one is perfect,"  "We are all human,"  and so on.  In the Corinthian church there was a man who lived with and was having sex with his father's wife.  When Paul wrote to the church he did not try to protect this man from trash talk, neither did he excuse his behavior.  Paul told the church to have nothing more to do with him until he repented and left the twisted relationship.  If the Corinthians were anything like churches today, there would be a group of people in the Corinthian church who would disagree with Paul and say that the man just needed should be forgiven and should not be pushed out of the church for his failings. After all, we all sin and isn't the Gospel about forgiveness? 

The Bible insists on discipline in the Christian community, but on the flip side, there may hypocrisy in those who are quick to cast stones at the guilty.  Ted Haggard and Jimmy Swaggart were vicious with others who sinned.  Swaggart exposed another competing pastor in his city for adultery which caused that preacher to lose his congregation.  Swaggart also railed out against pornography while indulging in it.  Haggard visited male prostitutes in private while fighting publicly against homosexuality.

All Sin Is Equal in God's Sight

Because the holiness of God is so underrated by our community, when these people fall, there is an abundance of followers who quickly pass off or downgrade the importance of the behaviors of their beloved leaders by claiming the silly and unbiblical notion that all sin is the same in God's eyes, not knowing that the New Testament differentiates sin unto death and sin not unto death as well forgivable sin and unforgivable sin. They also neglect to see that the Old Testament requires different measures of sacrifice and different restitution for different sins.  They also fail to see that Jesus called for people to make restitution to others before coming to visit God at the altar, and there is no way that restitution would be the same for every sin.

Even nature tells us that all sin is not equal.  If all sin were equal, then we should freely let the pedophiles lead children's Sunday School without judging them - after all, God has forgiven them.  If all sin were equal, then we should allow convicted rapists (just out of prison) take our teen aged daughters on Christian field trips - after all, they became Christian in prison and turned their lives around.  These people are forgiven and should be allowed in our churches, but they will and should pay a price for their misdeeds for the rest of their lives in many cases; we need to protect our churches and children from some forgiven people - and those forgiven people should be the first to insist, "Do not put me in a place where I am tempted."  If they have truly turned around and become Christian, then they will want to flee temptation as much as anyone around them wanting them to.

I will agree that even the smallest sin severs our relationship with God and must be taken to the cross, but all sin is not equal.